TAG Comps vs PSA - 2025 Terastal Umbreon EX SAR eBay Data

TAG Comps vs PSA is a key debate among Pokémon TCG collectors, especially regarding the 2025 Terastal Festival set. Many believe that TAG-graded cards fetch higher prices than PSA-graded copies, which can be pivotal for high-demand collectibles like the Umbreon EX Special Art Rare (SAR). Below, we’ll examine recently sold listings and display a quick snapshot of how these prices compare.

TAG Comps vs PSA: Terastal Festival Highlights

The 2025 Terastal Festival set stands out for its eye-catching holographic techniques and popular Pokémon like Umbreon. Buyers often prefer TAG Grading for its AI-driven approach and detailed reporting. Meanwhile, PSA is widely recognized with a broad collector base. These differences drive ongoing conversations about which service yields better final sale outcomes. To view more Terastal Festival cards, visit the Terastal Festival Collection .

PSA vs TAG Umbreon EX SAR Sales (December 2024–Present)

From December 2024 through early February 2025, PSA 10 versions of the Umbreon EX SAR often realized $520–$580. In contrast, TAG 10 copies sold in the $800–$900 range, suggesting a 35–55% premium. Below is a quick chart illustrating these average eBay prices for both auction and buy-it-now formats:

Although PSA has historically been a more recognizable name, the demand for TAG’s transparent, AI-based method appears to drive higher sales prices. For instance, one TAG 10 auction closed at $850 (Jan 15, 2025), while a PSA 10 Umbreon from the same set ended near $550 (Jan 11, 2025).

Key Observations

• PSA 10 Range: $520–$580 (Dec 2024–Feb 2025).
• TAG 10 Range: $800–$900, reflecting a 35–55% premium.
• Population Differences: Fewer TAG slabs on the market, contributing to higher asks.
• Buyer Confidence: Many collectors appreciate TAG’s detailed condition reports.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Grading Service

The TAG Comps vs PSA debate remains active for the 2025 Terastal Festival release. Based on current data, TAG-graded Umbreon EX SAR cards often surpass PSA-graded ones by a noticeable margin. As more TAG-graded examples enter the market, final values could shift, but right now a 35% premium is quite plausible and sometimes even conservative. Sellers and collectors should weigh brand familiarity against AI-driven grading benefits when deciding how to maximize their returns.